Hi Mike, I would think that the modern synthetic oils that are available to-day are loaded with detergents etc..
In an engine that uses pourred babbit bearings and a very inefficient by-pass oil filter, high detergent oils should be avoided.
With a good, quality non-detergent oil, the "dirt" will settle out, sit in the bottom of the oilpan and hopefully go out on an oil change. A detergent oil will keep the dirt in suspension which is tough on the bearings.