Your trophy gives you most of the information you need to evaluate the piece historically. It was made by the Poole Silver Company of Taunton, Massachusetts, probably just prior to the date the that the trophy was won in the early 20's. 1835 dates to when the Company was founded. The internet search engines may be able to help you on the team that won the trophy. I suspect it was a minor team and must admit my ignorance of sports and the time period. Good luck on your search.